Home > This is a Massacre, Not a War in Iraq

This is a Massacre, Not a War in Iraq

by Open-Publishing - Tuesday 19 October 2004

Wars and conflicts International Sam Hamod

By Sam Hamod

This is a massacre, not a war in Iraq. The U.S. bombing Samarra, Fallujah, Baghdad and other cities, killing hundreds of civilians and calling them terrorists is like the massacres of the Native Americans during America’s push westward.

In this case, it has to do with America’s push eastward.

What is also troubling is that no major media outlet, no major politician—none are callig this what it is, an immoral, unmitigated killing of hundreds of Iraqi civilians every week.

Those who are experts in Arabic have claimed for months that the man alleged to be Zarqawi is not really Zarqawi because he does not have the real Zarqawi’s Jordanian accent. But, the American military, we are positive by now, has created this mythical Zarqawi to allow it to mercilessly attack Fallujah and punish its inhabitants because they withstood the American ground attack and chased the Americans out. Even today, the Fallujhans have said aloud to Al Jazeera and other outlets, that they will come out into the streets and fight the Americans—but our country, America, is immoral and cowardly, every day attacking Fallujah by F16, Apache and long range cannon fire. In the process, killing hundreds of civilians, but as in the Viet Nam war, saying, "It’s just collateral damage and we are not responsible for that."

My question then, is who is responsible for the killings.
I point my finger at General Abizaid, a man who should know better. I also point the finger of guilt at his subordinate commanders in Iraq and all the way up to the two devils at the top of the pole, George W. Bush and Donald Rumsfeld. By now, it is obvious why Bush and his cronies do not want to support the International Criminal Court and are even attacking the court at the Hague—because they know that they are breaking international laws and that they would be pulled up, kicking and screaming ala Milosovich, to that court for their war crimes and crimes against humanity in Iraq.

It is time for Americans to speak up to stop this massacre.
We are killing Iraqis in the name of "Freedom" and "Democracy!"
How absurd, must we kill the Iraqis to "save them". This sounds almost like the old Salem Witch Trials, where they put people to death in order to save them. But it also smells of the aforementioned slaughter of the Native Americans by the jolly good American cavalry—ironically, it’s the same cavalry that is repeating its deeds 200 years later, but this time against Iraqis. For shame.

Also, shame on our media outlets, our church leaders, those phony Christians, Billy Graham, Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson—men who shall certainly be condemned to hell by God on the day of judgement. Some may say, I have no right to say such a thing, but all you have to do is see how they are supporting these atrocities—especially Billy Graham and his son, both men who had built reputations for decency but have now destroyed them with this endorsement of slaughter in Iraq.

As for Falwell and Robertson, they not only endorse the Iraq slaughter, they also are doing all they can to praise Sharon and Israel for their slaughter, on a daily basis for the past 3 years of Palestinians. They also cheer when Palestinian homes are bulldozed, as in the 200 taken down in the past month.

In the process, some at the UN have spoken out, even Kofi Annan, but people in America are not hearing. Instead, America is trying to distract the public with stories about Darfur, about the non-existant Zarqawi, about "staying the course" (as if there is a course and as if it is justified), and few are asking, "Just why are we in Iraq, after all, Saddam is gone?" We hear such nonsense as, "We have to stay to settle things down in Iraq." But President Jimmy Carter and most international experts say that we are the problem and that Iraqis could solve their own problems if we’d leave.
But, as most know, and this has been pointed out by Jane’s of London and other experts in the U.S. such as Chalmers Johnson, America intendes to build at least 2 dozen bases or more in Iraq to stay on—never to leave.

I want to say again, as I said in articles since Bush’s invasion of Iraq, we shall pay a heavy price for this slaughter of Iraqis who are Arabs and Muslims. This slaughter, this massacre has incensed the entire Muslim world.
America is no longer respected in any part of the Muslim world.
In fact, a recent poll in Egypt, one of our strongest allies in the Arab and Muslim world, showed that over 90% of the Egyptians are now angry at America. But what of the 1.6 billion Muslims in the world, many of them are so incensed that they will become militant against us. Our behavior has taken away any credibility moderates had, now the radicals can say, "See, moderation got you nowhere with America. They even kicked Cat Stevens out of America, a leading moderate in England, a man who had even given advice to the White House on how to deal with radicals."

Samuel Huntington in his book, The Clash of Civilizations, claimed Islam was intent on making a war on the West. This was not true, but what has happened is that Bush and his fundamentalist Christian friends are making war on Islam—it can be seen with American troops attacking Muslims in Iraq, in Afghanistan, in the Phillippines, in Indonesia, in Malaysia,
in Yemen, in assisting Israel with money, weapons and expertise in their killing of Palestinians.

America may win some battles, but it losing the larger war.
The entire world is condemning our behavior in Iraq as illegal and immoral. What is coming is the long term hatred of America by the majority of Muslims in the world, and some will become combatants in time—not necessarily in Iraq, but in their own countries. Bush and his massacre of Muslims is sowing anger, hatred, desire for revenge—in time, America will reap a whirlwind that the ignorant GW Bush has sown.
Make no mistake about it.

America has played its last cards as a moral world leader.
Our moral arguments now are laughable to the rest of the world.
The word has gotten out on how we tried to remove Chavez from office in Venezuela, have placed a puppet regime in Iraq to lord over the people ala Vichy in France in WWII, have supported Israel in its massacres of Palestinians, and the continued killing and bombings of innocents in Iraq and Afghanistan, while now threatening Syria, Iran and Lebanon.
It is obvious to any intelligent and moral observer that our the Bush team has gone out of its mind.

And one last point, have you noticed two important things that never get into the news: 1. Israel has the second largest supply of atomic weapons in the world and has threatened to use the, but you never hear that criticized or even admitted by America. 2. Bush is afraid of North Korea because it has atomic weapons, but also because China told him in no uncertain terms, "Keep your nose out of this area or we’ll bloody it for you and wreck your economy as well."

Our fearless leader is only good at killing innocent civiilans through attcks from the air with F16s, Apaches and long range missiles, then calling those killed "enemy combatants," "terrorists," or "insurgents." I hope more people in America will wake up before things get much worse. It is already too late in most cases for America to recover its place in the world. But, if we kick Bush out of office and replace his military commanders in the field, especially Myers and Abizaid, we may be able to salvage something—but it’s going to be a long, hard road and will take us decades and maybe centuries to ever again be trusted by any Muslims or Arabs in the world.

Let’s call it what it is in Iraq and Palestine, massacres, not wars. Somehow, it is as if Bush and Sharon are joined together at the hip and in their immoral hearts and minds.
Both are guilty of war crimes. We knew this about Sharon by recalling his infamous invasion of Lebanon in the 1980s; but we didn’t know how much Bush would follow Sharon’s lead and take America down this illegal and immoral path with him. Unfortunately, for America, Bush has, as President Carter said, "Destroyed our reputation in the world as a moral leader, it may take decades or more to repair the damage."

Just remember what I am saying, "This is a massacre, not a war."

The Iraqis have no planes, helicopters or tanks; the Palestinians have no planes, helicopters or tanks; but America does and uses them indiscriminately, as does Israel. America should take a cue from the resistance to Israel, some day it will come here, when the people in the Muslim and Arab worlds have had enough and decide to strike back.

Woe unto us for allowing the madman Bush to kill people in Iraq, Afghanistan and by proxy, in Palestine. Some day, as Malcolm X prophesied, "The chickens will come home to roost."

Sam Hamod is an expert on Islam and the Middle East; he is a former advisor to the State Department, editor of 3rd World News and Director of The Islamic Center of Wash, DC. Watch for his new book, in 2005, ESSAYS IN TIMES OF WAR. He may be reached at shamod@cox.net .


Forum posts

  • Erase this, you fucking piece of shit commie nazi collaborating motherfuckers! Europe CAN go to fucking hell. France, Germany, Spain, you’ll all a bunch of fucking LOSERS. I guess europe doesn’t have a past, huh? What a bunch of naive fucking COWARDS. Guess what? Americans no longer give a flying fuck about your countries. Relations will NEVER heal.


    • Well dirty mouth...you do not speak for the majority of Americans who want to have good relations with the rest of the world, and to find alternative resolutions to conflic that DO NOT INCLUDE KILLING AND VIOLENCE, so keep your dirty mouth to yourself you are not in the majority by a long way bub....

    • You guys need to wake up and smell the coffee. You are incredibly naive and have now idea whats going on in the world. Stop watching the BBC and reading French newspapers and maybe you’ll learn something...

  • I for one am SICK with guilt over what our country has done to so many innocent people. Most of the American people can see through the lies now, but Bush and Kerry both keep talking about the ’terrorists’ in Iraq and ’winning’. I dream of the day when we can finally admit what we have done, and apologize(as much as possible) for all the damage we have done. Lucky for us the Iraqi people(and the palestinians) seem to be so kind and understanding of the fact that it is our government that is evil, not neccessarily the American people. I’m not sure we will deserve their forgiveness though, standing and watching while your government is committing horrible atrocities makes us participants in that evil. But we are in the process of taking responsibility for our government, and our media......and we’re going to throw the bastards out!

  • Hamod is right on all points. As an American who did all I could do to stop bush before the war began and who has continued to write, call, protest and more, I am at a loss as to how to stop bush. If he is elected, he plans to invade Syria and Iran — who knows what else? Our country is going bankrupt, our leaders are morally bankrupt and half the American people are completely against the course bush is taking. What is the answer? Obviously, from some of the repugnant comments against Hamod, these people are part of the problem in America. Unthinking idiots.

  • Massacre? They call it genocide in some places. They call it a war crime in others.

    Americans call it freedom. Americans love it when they see terrorist babies with holes in their heads. Americans know, those are future bin ladens and long for the day when there is a Mcdonalds in every city in Iraq. Long live king W the bush.

    The guy above hates other countries...but loves epcot center!

    US soldiers are also being massacred, by our own government. When we use bunker busters or any kind of missile with DU(depleted uranium), guess who cleans it up? Nobody. So US soldiers get to rummage through cities eminating lovely uranium..."HEY WE FOUND THE WMD’S"..."IT’S JUST THAT WE’RE USING THEM ON YOU".

    While the soldiers muck through Iraq on a little tour, only to come home and have children with no lungs or born with no eyes...people shout "America the beautiful", little do they know we are, "america the murderers."

    Oh yeah, and don’t forget the little terrorists, they get to play in the rubble too.


  • Sorry, but you’re an idealist person with absolutely no knowledge of the real world.

    It is not a massacre in Iraq. We’re just killing people who want to destroy the democratic system there. George Bush did the right thing in attacking Iraq, one of the few things he did right. Now we’re helping people who’ve had no George Washington build a democratic country.

    And with your rambling about threatening Iran, Syria and Jordania: so what? As if these countries are perfect examples of freedom and democracy. The leaders of Iran are thousand times worse than Pat Robertson, Jerry Falwell and Billy Graham combined. It’s a GOOD thing that they are put under pressure.

  • Dear Sam,

    Thank God that there are men like you who are not afraid to tell the truth. It is so dreadful what we are doing to those poor innocent people. It is a repeat of what we did in Vietnam. I spent seven years in Vietnam throughout most of the war. I was a refugee advisor in the Mekong Delta and I witnessed on a regular basis the systematic slaughter of poor innocent Vietnamese. They wanted no part of the war. They told me countless times that it was not their war. It was a struggle between the U.S., Russia and China. They were the pawns in a ruthless power play.

    There were several Special Forces A-camps in the province. They would fire artillery shells at random into the countryside. Frequently they would hit a village killing everyone. The sight was horrible. But what was more horrible were the napalm drops. Human torches would race about screaming. However the White Phosphorus was even more dreadful. I shudder simply thinking about it.

    Senator Kerry was right on target. There was widespread atrocities committed by our troops. The reason that many Vietnam veterans deny this is because 70% were locked up in huge military bases and knew nothing of Vietnam. The 30% combat troops committed horrible crimes and they’ll admit it if confronted. They all carried packs of photos about in their wallets of dreadful atrocities they committed and posed for.


  • Dorothy Davies in the UK, endorsing everything you have said. My daughter and I find the newsreels heartbreaking, not only Iraq but in Israel too. Why is no one speaking out about Palestinians, we ask ourselves nightly, why are we allowing the slaughter of innocents to go on?

    Sam, all power to you and your pen, no matter how unwelcome the message might be to Bush supporters, it is time for all right thinking people to speak up and stop the slaughter.

    I wish you well.

  • Billy Graham is a Democrat and supports John Kerry.

  • Donald Rumsfeld, hmm, I guess you go to war with the piece of shit, Bush-chosen secretary of defence you have, not the one you want. May he be quickly forgetten for accplishing nothing note-worthy for the American people or the World.