Home > If John Kerry and George Bush don’t have a plan for leaving Iraq,Why don’t (…)

If John Kerry and George Bush don’t have a plan for leaving Iraq,Why don’t they ask Dennis Kucinich?

by Open-Publishing - Thursday 23 September 2004
12 comments

As It turns out Dennis Kucinich has been right every step of the way on this war, perhaps our leaders should think to listen to him now. Dennis Kucinich seems to be the only one speaking the truth with a clear vision of how to get the world out of the mess Bush has created. This was written after 500 deaths.

"The war in Iraq is over and the occupation has turned into a quagmire. The United States troops have become the targets of criminals and terrorists who are flowing into Iraq for the chance to kill Americans. The cost of the occupation keeps rising: The President has already asked for more than $155 billion to pay for it, and there is no end in sight. The United Nations is now in an impossible situation, where most of the members view the war and occupation of Iraq as a U.S. folly. Under these circumstances, the UN is unlikely to help. And UN assistance with a U.S. occupation would not allow the establishment of an Iraqi government that was acceptable to the Iraqi people.

"U.S. military casualties in Iraq have now exceeded 500, and the media has begun comparing the figure to the number of U.S. dead in Vietnam in 1965 prior to the significant expansion of U.S. operations there.

"Other Democrats join the Bush Administration in explaining that ’We can’t cut and run.’ I say we can’t continue the damage we are causing and cannot begin repairing it until we withdraw our occupying army. We must pay for what we destroyed. We must pay reparations to the families of innocent civilians we killed and injured. But we must work through the United Nations. We must allow the United Nations to facilitate the creation of a democratic government that will be acceptable to the Iraqi people. No government created by the United States will be. It is better that we recognize this now than after the next 500 deaths.

"If we stay the course it will do damage to American security. Iraq was not responsible for 9/11 and had no weapons of mass destruction. It was wrong to go in and it’s wrong to stay in. The demands of an occupation are overstretching our armed forces. And the extended deployment of reserve forces makes us vulnerable at home. The reserve call-ups include large numbers of firemen, policemen and other first responders who are needed for hometown security. Americans are asking, is there a way out? I say there is. This is my plan to get the UN in ... and the U.S. out of Iraq! This plan will bring our troops home within 90 days of UN approval, and strengthen American security.

"The following is the only detailed plan from any candidate for President that will quickly bring all U.S. troops home from Iraq.

1. The United States must ask the United Nations to manage the oil assets of Iraq until the Iraqi people are self-governing.
2. The United Nations must handle all the contracts: No more Halliburton sweetheart deals, No contracts to Bush Administration insiders, No contracts to campaign contributors. All contracts must be awarded under transparent conditions.
3. The United States must renounce any plans to privatize Iraq. It is illegal under both the Geneva and the Hague Conventions for any nation to invade another nation, seize its assets, and sell those assets. The Iraqi people, and the Iraqi people alone must have the right to determine the future of their country’s resources.
4. The United States must ask the United Nations to handle the transition to Iraqi self-governance. The UN must be asked to help the Iraqi people develop a Constitution. The UN must assist in developing free and fair elections.
5. The United States must agree to pay for what we blew up.
6. The United States must pay reparations to the families of innocent Iraqi civilian noncombatants killed and injured in the conflict.
7. The United States must contribute financially to the UN peacekeeping mission.
8. The United Nations, through its member nations, will commit 130,000 peacekeepers to Iraq on a temporary basis until the Iraqi people can maintain their own security.
9. UN troops will rotate into Iraq, and all U.S. troops will come home.
10. The United States will abandon policies of "preemption" and unilateralism and commit to strengthening the UN.

"I will work tirelessly to take America in a new direction, to gain approval of this plan at the United Nations, and to put it into action, bring all U.S. troops home in 90 days. Only if the United States takes a new direction will we be able to persuade the UN community to participate. Such a new direction is reflected in this 10-point plan.

"As President I will go to the UN and announce America’s intention to abide by this plan if approved by the UN.

"I will ask the UN Security Council to ratify a new resolution on Iraq that would deploy a multinational force under UN mandate0to keep the peace in Iraq while the interim Iraqi government receives UN support and a new Iraqi government is elected. It is my plan that within one month, the first UN troops and support personnel will arrive in Iraq, and the first U.S. troops will be sent home. UN peacekeeping troops and Iraqis who are commissioned as police and military will replace the U.S. In place of the U.S.-led Coalition Provisional Authority, the UN will open an office to direct the repair to infrastructure damaged by U.S. invasion. In two months, the UN will begin to conduct a census of the Iraqi population to lay groundwork for national elections. At the same time, new temporary rules for the election will be promulgated, guaranteeing universal suffrage on a one-person, one-vote basis. During the transition period, a Memorandum of Understanding between the American and UN force commanders for a turnover period will settle the question of who commands the troops. By the end of month three, all U.S. troops will have returned home.

"In month four, a major milestone will be reached when Iraqi sovereignty is established. A nationwide election will take place to elect representatives to a Constitutional Convention. The Convention will have two duties: 1) elect a temporary Prime Minister who appoints a cabinet to take over responsibility from the Iraqi Governing Council, and 2) draft a national constitution. Accountability of this Prime Minister is achieved by virtue of the fact that he can be recalled by a majority of the Convention.

"In one year, there will be nationwide elections pursuant to the new Constitution, which will install an elected government in Iraq.

"The U.S. owes a moral debt to the people of Iraq for the damage caused by the U.S. invasion. The U.S. will also owe a contribution to the UN to help Iraq make the transition to self-government. American taxpayers deserve that their contributions be handled in an accountable, highly visible manner. However, Americans are not required to build a state-of-the-art infrastructure as the Administration is planning. The Administration is ordering top-shelf technology from U.S. corporations for Iraq, paid for by U.S. taxpayers. Sweetheart deals have been awarded with billions of dollars to top corporations and political contributors. This is precisely what corrupts the Administration’s reconstruction efforts today. Instead, Iraqis should be employed to repair Iraq, and U.S. taxpayers should pay only for the damage caused by the U.S. invasion, including compensation for its victims. U.S. taxpayers should not be asked to furnish Iraq with what we do not have here!

"The war and occupation in Iraq have been costly in other ways too. One price America has paid is the loss of our moral authority in the world. The Administration launched an unprovoked attack on Iraq, and the premises of the war are proving to be false. This has cost us our credibility and done serious harm to America’s standing in the world. After the attacks of 9-11, the world felt sympathy for us. But this war and the occupation have squandered that sympathy, replacing it with dangerous anti-American sentiment throughout the world.

"America must make a dramatic reversal of course: we must acknowledge that the continued U.S. military presence in Iraq is counterproductive and destabilizing. We have a choice in front of us: either we change course, withdraw our troops and request that the UN move in, or we sink deeper into this occupation, with more U.S. casualties, ever higher financial costs, and diminished security for all Americans.

"We need a real change. My plan will bring the troops home in 90 days, transfer authority to the UN with provisions made toward a rapid transition to Iraqi sovereignty, and save billions of dollars. It will enable the U.S. to think creatively about how to deal with threats that come not from established countries with conventional armies (our armed forces are more than adequate to that task), but rather threats that come from networks of terrorists and criminals who use unconventional means to injure Americans. We must also apprehend the criminals who masterminded the 9-11 attacks on our nation, a goal that is hindered by the occupation of Iraq. Lastly, my plan will also enable the U.S. to redirect scarce resources to rebuild America."

Forum posts

  • "As It turns out Dennis Kucinich has been right every step of the way on this war, perhaps our leaders should think to listen to him now. Dennis Kucinich seems to be the only one speaking the truth with a clear vision of how to get the world out of the mess Bush has created. This was written after 500 deaths"...

    ...And we are now on our way to substantively over 1,000 US deaths, approximately 12,000 Iraqi deaths (and a similar approximate number in Afghanistan). As a long time "Nobody But Dennis" supporter/volunteer I want to say "Thank You" for your article. The more I read of late, the more I find that people are realizing what a horrific "mistake" has been made going into Iraq. A Republican senator recently stated that the war in Iraq was a mistake. A conservative democrat in the House also recently stated he regretted voting to go to war in Iraq and it was the one vote that he most regretted in his entire 30 year career in Congress. More and more military famlies are fed up with the situation and want their loved ones to come home. Yes, Dennis was right from the very beginning and while I’m cheered by the support you express in your article for Dennis, I’m also sad that he is not the nominee for President. But you are so right ---Bush and Kerry do not have an exit strategy so JUST ASK DENNIS!

    Peace (NOW!)
    Susan Lynn Rapp
    Kucinich Supporter/Volunteer
    for Kerry/Edwards

  • I wonder if we offered to let the UN take over the oil resources, and they then created a permanent fund like the state of Alaska and distributed profits to all Iraqis...would the Iraqis be happier? What if we gave Iraqis the jobs rebuilding their own infrastructure which they are perfectly capable of doing?

    It seems to me that if the Iraqis felt they were treated fairly, were given the profits of their own resources and given control over their own country, if they were truly liberated of American Occupation forces, Sadr’s militia will put down their arms and only a small peacekeeping force would be needed, not the 130,000 coalition troops of today.

    Sadr has stated that his militia will accept a peacekeeping force "made up of muslim countries or countries that did not join the coalition such as Russia, France or Germany." Perhaps if the truth were made clear, muslim countries will step forward to help.

    It is time for an international dialogue on how to start the real repair of Iraqi society and set the healing in motion.

    • Agreed. Either you are part of the problem or part of the solution. However, Al-Sadr’s motivation is merely in the interest of self-promotion, as he obviously couldn’t care less for providing humanitairan relief and maintaining stability. Kucinich’s motivations paralell that of Al-Sadr - and sadly, neither one of them have a clue.

    • the only problem with dennis kucinich is that he wasn’t rich enough or tall enough. doesn’t say much for the american voters. can you say SHALLOW?

    • I don’t know what Al-Sadr’s motivations are, however I wouldn’t say that Kucinich’s are all about self-promotion. I think Dennis does care about humanitarian relief, and helping the Iraqi people maintain stability. Uncertainty can be a fertile ground for creative solutions and seeing new possiblities. I wouldn’t say either one of them doesn’t have a clue; I’d say they are honest about no perfect solutions and seem to be open to dialogue.

      Dialogue can be difficult in our culture, because we tend toward valuing answers and taking charge, instead of seeing possibilities and listening.

  • It is not too late to start listening- Dennis Kucinich has the keys to ending this unbearable injustice

    Ask the United Nations to manage the oil assets of Iraq and handle all the contracts

    "The United States must renounce any plans to privatize Iraq. It is illegal under both the Geneva and the Hague Conventions for any nation to invade another nation, seize its assets, and sell those assets. The Iraqi people, and the Iraqi people alone must have the right to determine the future of their country’s resources.. "

    Does this seem like too much to ask? The American people may be dumbed down, but the Iraqis see clearly what is happening, which might just contribute to our soldiers being targets.

    Another key point- take responsibility, apologize

    "The United States must agree to pay for what we blew up, pay reparations to the families of innocent Iraqi civilian noncombatants killed and injured in the conflict. "

    This is the only way toward progress in Iraq. It seems currently that the media and the politicians are stalling, running the clock until the election and then no matter who is in office it is back to mindlessly killing the Iraqis until we ’win’. Staying the course is not an option for providing peace and stability in Iraq.

    This is a quote from Moqtada Al-Sadr- has this made it to the mainstream media?
    "I address my enemy Bush. You are now fighting an entire nation, from south to north, east to west, and we advise you to withdraw from our country. I call on the American people to stand beside their brethren Iraqi people who are suffering an injustice by your rulers and the occupying army, to help them in the transfer of power to honest Iraqis."

    • Your Al-Sadr quote portrays a side of Al-Sadr seldom if ever shown in American mainstream media but is a side which needs to be shown. Thank you for your quote. Hope more people begin to see all people as brothers and sisters of the human family, think about news reports, why people do what they do, question governmental actions and never blindly accept harmful actions.

  • "The Americans do not care about the Iraqis. They don’t care if they get killed, because they don’t care about the citizens," said Abu Mohammed, 50, who was a major general in Saddam Hussein’s army in Baghdad. "The Americans keep criticizing Saddam for the mass graves. How many graves are the Americans making in Iraq?"

    More Iraqi Civilians Killed by US Forces Than By Insurgents, Data Shows
    http://www.commondreams.org/headlines04/0925-02.htm

  • Thank God for Dennis Kucinich.

  • The reason THEY wont ask Dennis Kucinich was the reasoning to go into Iraq in the first place. It was for the oil and to establish a military presence on Iraqi soil in the heart of the middle east.
    John Kerry and Bush are members of the same Illuminati family who want to control the world through corporate fascism. The end game for them is not peace and security its growth and continuance of the military industrial complex. Only an "endless war on terrorism" will benefit this aim (replacing the cold war as the reason for 400 billion dollar US military budgets).

    Wake up America - 9/11 was an inside job - by the same folks that pursue endless war on the world.

    • U really know what ur talking about. Me and my family believe the same thing and that both bush and kerry are no good. the only reason i saved this to my favorites is because of your entry. I suggest u watch out though. The

  • Why don’t they ask Dennis Kucinich? Indeed. And how about Ralph Nader, Colin Powell and others who have had reservations about this war? It is interesting how things have turned out. The difficulty is an all-American phenomenon: Can we be permitted to make errors? How do we look at our errors in judgment? What do we do about them?
    Ask the "free" women and men of the world what to do. By "free" I mean an attempt to let go of the shackles of patriarchy and an exaggerated masculine energy that insists on "ruling" the world. In this context we have a chance of finding lasting peace, which means no war; conflicts, yes/war, no.